In polls, about two thirds of Americans say Roe should remain

Republicans are lying about Roe v

canada goose outlet hong kong Republicans are lying. canada goose outlet hong kong

canada goose premium outlet That may not be much of a surprise in the age of Donald Trump, the most dishonest president in American history, who just set a new personal best by making 103 public false claims in a single week, equaling what he normally accomplishes in a month. canada goose premium outlet

canada goose factory outlet vancouver But as we await Trump’s nomination of a Supreme Court justice to replace the retiring Anthony M. Kennedy, the entire GOP has decided that the best way to advocate this nominee is simply to lie about what they want and what that justice will do on the cheap canada goose uk court. That nominee will also lie, or at the very least be intentionally, egregiously deceptive, in their confirmation hearings. And why shouldn’t they all do it? The strategy has worked so well before. canada goose factory outlet vancouver

canada goose outlet paypal I’m focusing specifically on Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision validating women’s right to abortion. Republicans know full Canada Goose online well that their position on this issue that Roe should be overturned so states can begin outlawing abortion is terribly unpopular. In polls, about two thirds of Americans say Roe should remain the law of the land. But overturning canada goose factory sale Roe is conservative dogma. So when there’s a nominee for the high court, everyone on the right agrees that once again they have to distort, dissemble and deceive if they’re to succeed in getting their nominee confirmed. canada goose outlet paypal

canada goose victoria parka outlet Let’s start with a brief tour of history before we canadian goose jacket get to what’s happening right now. The template for Republican nominees was set decades ago, and it goes like this: No matter what the senators ask during your confirmation hearings, you must do two canada goose things. First, refuse to answer anything too specific about Roe, citing the need to stay objective for future cases. Second, give hints that, no matter what you’ve said or how you’ve ruled in canada goose uk black friday the past, you might be willing to uphold it, even if that idea is utterly preposterous. Here are some examples: canada goose victoria parka outlet

canada goose outlet online uk Antonin Scalia (1986): “I assure you, I have no agenda. I am not going onto the court with a list of things that I want to do. There are doubtless laws on the books apart from abortion that I might not agree with, that I might think are misguided, perhaps some that I might even think in the largest sense are immoral in the results that Canada Goose Online they produce. In no way would I let that influence my determination of how they apply.” Clarence Canada Goose Outlet Thomas (1991): “I believe the Constitution protects the right to privacy. And I have no reason or agenda to prejudge the issue or to predispose to rule one way or the other on the issue of abortion, which is a difficult issue. Senator, your question to me was did I debate the contents of Roe v. Wade, the outcome in Roe v. Wade, buy canada goose jacket cheap do I have this day an buy canada goose jacket opinion, a personal opinion on the outcome in Roe v. Wade; and my Canada Goose Parka answer to you is that I do not.” John G. Roberts Jr. (2005): “Well, beyond that, [Roe v. Wade is] settled as a precedent of the court, entitled to respect under principles of stare decisis. And those principles, applied in the Casey case, explain when cases should be revisited and when they should not. And it is settled as a precedent of the court, yes.” Samuel A. Alito Jr. (2006): “That [a document in which he declared that the Constitution provides no right to abortion] was a statement that I made at a prior period of time when I was performing a different role, and as I said yesterday, when someone becomes a judge, you really have to canada goose uk outlet put aside the things that you did as a lawyer at prior points in your legal career and think about legal issues the way a judge thinks about legal issues.” Neil M. Gorsuch (2017): “I’m not in a position to tell you whether I’d personally like or dislike any precedent. That’s not relevant to Canada Goose sale my job Precedent deserves our respect. And to come in and think that just because I’m new or the latest thing I’d know better than everybody who comes before me would be an act of hubris.” In contrast, when the liberal justices were asked the same question in their confirmation hearings, they were perfectly forthright, saying that yes, under the Constitution canada goose clearance there is a right to abortion and they’d vote to uphold Roe. canada goose outlet online uk

canada goose outlet england What’s perhaps most remarkable is that canada goose black friday sale everyone understands that all these conservative justices would absolutely overturn Roe if they got the chance, yet somehow this dance of the seven veils they do in their confirmation hearings is accepted not as an act of deception but just what we should expect, or at worst treated as clever gamesmanship. canada goose outlet england

canada goose outlet black friday sale It’s not just the nominees themselves. Republicans at all levels, when asked about whether the next justice should be a vote to overturn Roe, will say that all they want is a justice who will objectively follow the law, and they neither know nor care what the nominee’s views on abortion are. “Judges must interpret the law fairly and apply it evenhandedly. Judicial decisions must not flow from judges’ personal philosophies or preferences, but from the honest assessment of the words and actual meaning of the law,” says Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell(R Ky.). canada goose outlet black friday sale

canada goose outlet niagara falls This morning on NPR, the chief counsel of the Judicial Crisis Network, a group devoted to getting uk canada goose more conservative judges on the courts, called the idea that they wanted to overturn Roe unicorndesigns “a lot canada goose coats on sale of scaremongering,” and said that “it would be inappropriate Canada Goose Outlet for any of them to prejudge that case themselves. cheap Canada Goose And I think it’s unlikely that the court would ever get that square question presented to it anyway.” It’s not canada goose store like abortion will come before the Supreme Court again, so what are you worried about? canada goose outlet niagara falls

canada goose outlet toronto address The truth, of course, is that Roe will come before the court very quickly, because Republican run states have been passing more and more canada goose uk shop restrictive laws, some with the express purpose of creating a case they hoped would result in Roe being overturned if the makeup of the Supreme Court were to change. For example, in May, Iowa passed a law banning abortion after a fetal heartbeat can be detected, which is generally around six weeks into a pregnancy, before many women even realize they’re pregnant. The whole point was to overturn Roe. “We need to create vehicles that will allow the Supreme Court possibly to reach back and take this case, and to take up an anti abortion case,” said one of the Republican legislators supporting it. canada goose outlet toronto address

canada goose outlet store uk The president has said he will be picking his new justice from a list provided to him in 2016 by conservative activists. While many of those on the list have never ruled on an abortion case or said anything publicly about it, the ones who have made their hostility clear indeed, they never would have gotten on the list if the activists had any reason to suspect they wouldn’t vote to overturn Roe. William Pryor, an appeals court judge on the list, has uk canada goose outlet calledRoe “the worst abomination of constitutional law in our history.” Another potential nominee, Amy Coney Barrett, has referred to Roe as “an erroneous decision.” canada goose outlet store uk

canada goose stockists uk But I’m sure if they were nominated they’d say that they’ll put their personal views aside and look at every case with fresh, canada goose coats unbiased eyes. canada goose stockists uk

canada goose outlet eu Ironically, the only one telling the truth about this question is Trump. During his final debate with Hillary Clinton in 2016, he was asked whether Roe should be overturned, and he responded, “Well, if we put another two or perhaps three justice on, that’s really what’s going to be that will happen. And that’ll happen automatically, in my opinion, because canada goose clearance sale I am putting pro life justices on the court.” canada goose outlet eu

canada goose outlet uk For once, we ought to believe him. And not let his allies get away with denying what everyone knows is true canada goose outlet uk.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.